Gulfstream

Entry Posted July 21, 2008

http://www.tnr.com/story_print.html?id=69067f1c-d089-474b-
a8a0-945d1deb420b
Negative, rather political review of Naomi Klein’s The Shock Doctrine: “But Klein was intellectually unfazed. Rather than re-think the economicist premises of her recent radicalism, she set out to synthesize her old worldview with the post-9/11 world. … Doggedly connecting the dots, she discovered that the Iraq war was—guess what?—part of the same economic tissue that connected Nike and the World Trade Organization. Klein is nothing if not a totalistic thinker. Everything always adds up, and darkly.” 22:59

Delicious tags:

What others say about this link

Josh Xiong | Neocon Blues (joshxiong.com):
… more regulation and a need for more taxes and more government programs. The financial crisis is about the former, and it is a debate about how we can make capitalist markets work better, and not how we can diminish the market altogether. Of-course,Naomi Klein …

Hidden History (hidhist.wordpress.com):
… been broken. In recent months, several articles and reports have come out claiming to debunk my thesis. The most prominent are a “background paper” published by The Cato Institute, extended into a full length book in Swedish (!), anda lengthy essayin The New Republic by senior editor Jonathan Chait. Several readers have written to asking me to respond to these attacks, if only to help them defend the book more effectively. I resisted at first (clinging to my summer vacation) but I appreciate the feedback and severa …

Ben Casnocha: The Blog (ben.casnocha.com):
… sweeping generalizations, or humorless nitpicking that leave even agreeable readers feeling sympathetic for the person on the other end. If you want an example of a professional, thoughtful, detailed, and nonetheless devastating critique of a thesis,read Jon Chait's review …

Kate/A/blog (kateablog.blogspot.com):
… interest quickly from one "bestseller" on the list to the next and it takes a lot of blow and hard to keep your book front and center at the cash register. Klein addresses one such attack on The Shock Doctrine from Jonathan Chait in an article atThe New Republic, title Dead Left Lol, how appropriate. Klein claims she resisted responding to the "attacks" but now feels compelled to do so for her fans have spoken and request it. It seems some disagree with Klein's portrayal of Milton Friedman as a supporter …

Reflektioner (bjornaxen.wordpress.com):
… Nu har Naomi Klein besvarat kritiken från Johan Norberg (eller rättare sagt: Cato - hon benämner honom aldrig) ochJonathan Chaitvilkas kritik av boken var rätt så likartad trots deras ideologiska skillnader. Norberg har så klart lovat besvara kritiken (vilket han gör här ). Utan att gå in i bokens alla detaljer vill jag bara säga det Kleins försvar inte &# …

More or Less Bunk (moreorlessbunk.wordpress.com):
… When UD first showed me Jonathan Chait’s hostile review of Naomi Klein’s The Shock Doctrinein The New Republica few weeks ago, I bit my tongue. Heaven knows the intellectual history of free market conservatism is not my strong suit. It didn’t help that I hadn’t read Klein since it came out almost a year ago. Thank goodness Naomi Klein has now responded to that revi …

HOW TO FURNISH A ROOM (howtofurnisharoom.blogspot.com):
… But still Jonathan (Big Con) Chaittakes issuewith Naomi Klein's Shock Doctrine. "Like every conspiracy theory, Klein's account of the fate of the world finally lacks internal logic. She points to one instance of American soldiers dismembering Iraqi passenger planes, inflicting "$100 million worth …

Nonicoclolasos (nonicoclolasos.wordpress.com):
… kriser för att driva igenom en politik som få egentligen vill ha, har rönt stor uppmärksamhet (vilket jag har skrivit om här och här). Själv har jag inte läst den men kan konstatera att vissa finner den osaklig — se t.ex. recensioner avJonathan Chaitoch Tyler Cowen samt Johan Norbergs analys — medan andra hyllar den. Intressant nog återfinns två högst respektabla personer i hyllningskören: ekonomipristagaren Joseph Stiglitz och filosofen John Gray …

P e r ∙ C r u c e m ∙ a d ∙ L u c e m (cruciality.wordpress.com):
… by Michael A. Sells, and The Muslims of Bosnia-Herzegovina: Their Historic Development from the Middle Ages to the Dissolution of Yugoslavia by edited by Mark Pinson. Jonathan Chait offers a hard-hittingreviewof The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism by Naomi Klein. Jim Gordon concludes his series of reflections on an ‘emotionally demanding and theologically enjoyable encounter’ with Hans Küng …

Gulfstream – Beebo (beebo.org):
… http://www.tnr.com/story_print.html?id=69067f1c-d089-474b- a8a0-945d1deb420bNegative, rather political review of Naomi Klein’s The Shock Doctrine: “But Klein was intellectually unfazed. Rather than re-think the economicist premises of her recent radicalism, she set out to synthesize her old worldview with the post-9/11 …

The View from Seymour (crofsblogs.typepad.com):
… Dead Left …

The New Editor (www.theneweditor.com):
… Jonathan Chait reviews Naomi Klein's book, The Shock Doctrine: The Rise of Disaster Capitalism, taking apart the anti-corporate, anti-globalization themes that run through Klein's arguments. Chait writes,in part: The Shock Doctrine has a single, uncomplicated explanation for everything that ails us. It identifies the fundamental driving force of the last three decades to be the worldwide spread of free-market absolutism as it was formulated by Milton Friedman …

NZBC (www.nzbc.net.nz):
… here. He’s a bit negative about it: “the pseudo-clarity of a conspiracy theorist” is one of his milder comments. He is devastating on the way she: identifies the Iraq war as a “careful and faithful application of unrestrained Chicago School …

Slog | The Stranger | Seattle's Only Newspaper (www.thestranger.com):
… Jonathan Chait’scriticisms of Naomi Klein’s bestseller The Shock Doctrine are accurate. Not one of his points misses its mark. I will briefly present and explain two direct hits. 1) On the matter of incompetence and its absence from her assessment of disaster …

Gulfstream – Beebo (beebo.org):
… http://www.tnr.com/story_print.html?id=69067f1c-d089-474b- a8a0-945d1deb420bNegative, rather political review of Naomi Klein’s The Shock Doctrine: “But Klein was intellectually unfazed. Rather than re-think the economicist premises of her recent radicalism, she set out to synthesize her old worldview with the post-9/11 …

Slog | The Stranger | Seattle's Only Newspaper (slog.thestranger.com):
… Jonathan Chait’scriticisms of Naomi Klein’s bestseller The Shock Doctrine are accurate. Not one of his points misses its mark. I will briefly present and explain two direct hits. 1) On the matter of incompetence and its absence from her assessment of disaster …

Someone Say Grace (someonesaygrace.blogspot.com):
… Despite a cultural consensus continually lowering the bar, there may be a postmodern battle for decency going on. The most successful and opportunistic art forger of the 20th century made a fortune swindling the Nazis. More here. The New New Left isstillthe old failed Marxism. Is it a compliment to be the "new Noam Chomsky"? …

That's the Press, Baby (davisullblog.blogspot.com):
… print remains a technology in search of a business plan that, like the 13th Imam, is still in occlusion. The best way to help print is to Put Ideas on the Table. Lots of them. Counterattack can be the best defense. Milton Friedman is quoted in thecurrent New Republic-- actually he is quoted by Naomi Klein in "The Shock Doctrine," which then is quoted by reviewer Jonathan Chait, but let's assume that someone, perhaps a copy editor, verified that Friedman actually said this -- "Only a crisis -- actual or perceived -- …

Gulfstream – Beebo (beebo.org):
… http://www.tnr.com/story_print.html?id=69067f1c-d089-474b-a8a0-945d1deb420b …

Spot-On (www.spot-on.com):
… s important archeological sites - the ones that had been looted? Well, the looting was an urban myth... more She was the new Chomsky, the young woman to re-invent politics for a new generation. Then came 9/11...morePsych departments won't teach Freud, nor is Marx taught in econ, while Hegel hardly figures in philosophy. In the mall of education, they are now boutique thinkers... more Visit A&L Daily > …

(Links provided by Technorati.)